02.12.2011, Результаты многокритериальной оптимизации

Материал из SRNS
Перейти к: навигация, поиск
(→‎L1SC)
 
(не показаны 32 промежуточные версии 1 участника)
Строка 1: Строка 1:
−
<accesscontrol>SuperUsers</accesscontrol>
 
 
<summary>Результаты расчетов</summary>
 
<summary>Результаты расчетов</summary>
  
Строка 10: Строка 9:
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
 
!Signal  
 
!Signal  
−
!Antijamming<br>w=0.08
+
!Antijamming<br>w=8.00
−
!Astronomy<br>w=0.13  
+
!Astronomy<br>w=2.00  
−
!Accurancy<br>w=0.15  
+
!Accurancy<br>w=9.00  
−
!MultiPath<br>w=0.08  
+
!MultiPath<br>w=6.00  
−
!Inter from GPS<br>w=0.08
+
!Inter from<br>w=3.00
−
!Inter to GPS<br>w=0.08
+
!Inter to<br>w=1.00
−
!Search<br>w=0.15
+
!Search<br>w=8.00
−
!Complexity<br>w=0.40
+
!Complexity<br>w=10.00
−
!Intra<br>w=0.08
+
!Intra<br>w=7.00
 
!Norm
 
!Norm
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(0.250, 0.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.970 || 0.140 || 0.792 || 0.000 || 0.966 || 0.972 || 0.145 || 0.996 || 0.989 || 0.4448
+
|BPSK(1.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.613 || 0.201 || 0.481 || 0.910 || 0.968 || 0.974 || 0.304 || 0.465 || 0.603 || 11.2942
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(0.500, 0.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.582 || 0.727 || 0.397 || 0.000 || 0.949 || 0.961 || 0.304 || 0.868 || 0.608 || 0.3888
+
|BPSK(2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.226 || 0.463 || 0.241 || 0.622 || 0.936 || 0.951 || 0.638 || 0.731 || 0.226 || 10.6568
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.195 || 1.000 || 0.198 || 0.000 || 0.902 || 0.927 || 0.638 || 1.000 || 0.226 || 0.4452
+
|BPSK(1.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.387 || 0.431 || 0.321 || 0.747 || 0.952 || 0.963 || 0.478 || 0.731 || 0.383 || 11.0965
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(0.250, 0.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.886 || 0.485 || 0.614 || 0.000 || 0.947 || 0.959 || 0.145 || 0.998 || 0.833 || 0.4398
+
|BPSK(1.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.489 || 0.350 || 0.386 || 0.824 || 0.960 || 0.969 || 0.389 || 0.931 || 0.484 || 13.0092
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(0.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.000 || 1.000 || 0.000 || 0.987 || 0.988 || 0.145 || 0.997 || 1.000 || 0.4553
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(0.500, 0.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.582 || 0.727 || 0.397 || 0.888 || 0.949 || 0.961 || 0.304 || 0.868 || 0.608 || 13.1624
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(0.500) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.117 || 1.000 || 0.000 || 1.000 || 1.000 || 0.145 || 0.997 || 1.000 || 0.4559
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(1.000, 1.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.195 || 1.000 || 0.198 || 0.615 || 0.902 || 0.927 || 0.638 || 1.000 || 0.226 || 12.6465
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(0.500) at 1570<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.842 || 1.000 || 0.000 || 0.000 || 0.000 || 0.145 || 0.997 || 1.000 || 0.4548
+
|BPSK(2.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.102 || 0.599 || 0.192 || 0.521 || 0.919 || 0.938 || 0.815 || 0.997 || 0.101 || 12.8749
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(0.750) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.774 || 0.091 || 0.642 || 0.000 || 0.976 || 0.980 || 0.228 || 0.804 || 0.759 || 0.3659
+
|BPSK(1.000) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.613 || 0.360 || 0.481 || 0.910 || 0.975 || 0.979 || 0.304 || 0.908 || 0.603 || 13.7449
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(1.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.613 || 0.201 || 0.481 || 0.000 || 0.968 || 0.974 || 0.304 || 0.908 || 0.603 || 0.3960
+
|BPSK(3.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.844 || 0.160 || 0.439 || 0.905 || 0.927 || 1.000 || 0.997 || 0.000 || 13.5461
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(1.000) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.613 || 0.360 || 0.481 || 0.000 || 0.975 || 0.979 || 0.304 || 0.908 || 0.603 || 0.3981
+
|BPSK(0.750) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.774 || 0.091 || 0.642 || 1.002 || 0.976 || 0.980 || 0.228 || 0.804 || 0.759 || 14.6179
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(1.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.489 || 0.350 || 0.386 || 0.000 || 0.960 || 0.969 || 0.389 || 0.931 || 0.484 || 0.4029
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(0.250, 0.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.886 || 0.485 || 0.614 || 0.808 || 0.947 || 0.959 || 0.145 || 0.998 || 0.833 || 15.7857
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(1.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.387 || 0.431 || 0.321 || 0.000 || 0.952 || 0.963 || 0.478 || 0.731 || 0.383 || 0.3313
+
|BPSK(0.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.000 || 1.000 || 1.092 || 0.987 || 0.988 || 0.145 || 0.465 || 1.000 || 16.4224
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.226 || 0.463 || 0.241 || 0.000 || 0.936 || 0.951 || 0.638 || 0.731 || 0.226 || 0.3342
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(0.250, 0.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.970 || 0.140 || 0.792 || 1.000 || 0.966 || 0.972 || 0.145 || 0.996 || 0.989 || 17.4602
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(2.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.102 || 0.599 || 0.192 || 0.000 || 0.919 || 0.938 || 0.815 || 0.997 || 0.101 || 0.4383
+
|BPSK(0.500) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.117 || 1.000 || 1.092 || 1.000 || 1.000 || 0.145 || 0.908 || 1.000 || 18.1902
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BPSK(3.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.844 || 0.160 || 0.000 || 0.905 || 0.927 || 1.000 || 0.997 || 0.000 || 0.4527
+
|BPSK(0.500) at 1570<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.842 || 1.000 || 1.092 || 0.000 || 0.000 || 0.145 || 0.997 || 1.000 || 18.4540
 
|}
 
|}
  
Строка 55: Строка 54:
  
 
{| class="wikitable sortable" border="1"  
 
{| class="wikitable sortable" border="1"  
−
|+ Multi-objective optimization for L1SC signal
+
|+ Multi-objective optimization for L1SC signal (Top 15)
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
 
!Signal  
 
!Signal  
Строка 62: Строка 61:
 
!Accurancy<br>w=6.00   
 
!Accurancy<br>w=6.00   
 
!MultiPath<br>w=2.00   
 
!MultiPath<br>w=2.00   
−
!Inter from GPS<br>w=2.00  
+
!Inter from<br>w=2.00  
−
!Inter to GPS<br>w=1.00  
+
!Inter to<br>w=1.00  
 
!Search<br>w=6.00
 
!Search<br>w=6.00
 
!Complexity<br>w=6.00
 
!Complexity<br>w=6.00
Строка 69: Строка 68:
 
!Norm
 
!Norm
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(3.250, 1.750) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 1.000 || 0.848 || 0.971 || 0.000 || 0.822 || 0.891 || 0.559 || 0.739 || 0.929 || 14.8836
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.201 || 0.074 || 0.659 || 0.074 || 0.600 || 0.690 || 0.816 || 0.666 || 0.402 || 8.7330
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(6.125, 1.750) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.036 || 0.151 || 0.525 || 0.000 || 0.000 || 0.000 || 0.559 || 0.900 || 0.985 || 12.1448
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.250, 2.625) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.079 || 0.210 || 0.630 || 0.064 || 0.508 || 0.573 || 0.857 || 0.885 || 0.311 || 8.9755
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(3.250, 1.875) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.936 || 0.887 || 0.969 || 0.000 || 0.821 || 0.888 || 0.599 || 0.875 || 0.803 || 14.1925
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.201 || 0.694 || 0.659 || 0.074 || 0.530 || 0.601 || 0.816 || 0.774 || 0.402 || 9.1299
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(3.750, 1.875) at 1568<math>f_b</math> || 0.915 || 0.610 || 0.878 || 0.000 || 0.924 || 0.910 || 0.599 || 0.912 || 1.000 || 15.1643
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.625, 2.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.063 || 0.494 || 0.578 || 0.056 || 0.299 || 0.319 || 0.734 || 0.892 || 0.524 || 9.4447
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.125, 1.875) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.171 || 0.953 || 0.621 || 0.000 || 0.593 || 0.631 || 0.599 || 0.978 || 0.749 || 11.1638
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.250, 2.625) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.079 || 0.848 || 0.630 || 0.064 || 0.421 || 0.547 || 0.857 || 0.994 || 0.311 || 9.4994
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.625, 1.875) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.166 || 0.415 || 0.577 || 0.000 || 0.216 || 0.240 || 0.599 || 0.872 || 0.894 || 11.6155
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(6.000, 2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.718 || 0.538 || 0.050 || 0.080 || 0.083 || 0.639 || 0.676 || 0.720 || 9.7748
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(3.250, 2.000) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.889 || 0.910 || 0.967 || 0.000 || 0.825 || 0.886 || 0.639 || 0.750 || 0.665 || 13.0509
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(3.000, 3.000) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.453 || 0.418 || 0.913 || 0.071 || 0.833 || 0.845 || 1.000 || 0.644 || 0.000 || 9.9164
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.000, 2.000) at 1567<math>f_b</math> || 0.750 || 0.976 || 0.822 || 0.000 || 0.928 || 0.917 || 0.639 || 0.676 || 0.852 || 13.1236
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.625, 2.250) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.063 || 0.915 || 0.578 || 0.056 || 0.180 || 0.264 || 0.734 || 1.000 || 0.524 || 9.9347
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.000, 2.000) at 1568<math>f_b</math> || 0.750 || 0.615 || 0.822 || 0.000 || 0.899 || 0.918 || 0.639 || 0.709 || 0.852 || 13.0900
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.750, 2.375) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.330 || 0.987 || 0.692 || 0.082 || 0.692 || 0.728 || 0.775 || 0.836 || 0.502 || 10.1288
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 0.976 || 0.650 || 0.000 || 0.756 || 0.804 || 0.639 || 0.748 || 0.770 || 11.1337
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.750, 2.375) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.330 || 0.273 || 0.692 || 0.082 || 0.642 || 0.646 || 0.775 || 0.944 || 0.502 || 10.2743
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 0.561 || 0.650 || 0.000 || 0.538 || 0.648 || 0.639 || 0.607 || 0.770 || 10.6384
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 0.561 || 0.650 || 0.076 || 0.538 || 0.648 || 0.639 || 0.607 || 0.770 || 10.6395
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 0.406 || 0.650 || 0.000 || 0.427 || 0.518 || 0.639 || 0.716 || 0.770 || 10.8241
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(2.750, 2.750) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.669 || 0.723 || 0.996 || 0.088 || 1.000 || 1.000 || 0.897 || 0.568 || 0.188 || 10.7539
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1567<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 1.000 || 0.650 || 0.000 || 0.658 || 0.688 || 0.639 || 0.748 || 0.770 || 11.1096
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.500, 2.250) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.462 || 0.130 || 0.732 || 0.092 || 0.750 || 0.732 || 0.734 || 0.791 || 0.628 || 10.8240
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(6.000, 2.000) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.718 || 0.538 || 0.000 || 0.080 || 0.083 || 0.639 || 0.676 || 0.720 || 9.7743
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.000) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.352 || 0.406 || 0.650 || 0.076 || 0.427 || 0.518 || 0.639 || 0.716 || 0.770 || 10.8252
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.250, 2.125) at 1567<math>f_b</math> || 0.606 || 0.488 || 0.776 || 0.000 || 0.884 || 0.862 || 0.693 || 0.928 || 0.725 || 12.2867
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(2.875, 2.875) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.559 || 0.848 || 0.953 || 0.079 || 0.856 || 0.867 || 0.938 || 0.856 || 0.095 || 10.8732
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
== Частотный диапазон L2 ==
 +
 
 +
=== L2OC ===
 +
 
 +
{| class="wikitable sortable" border="1"
 +
|+ Multi-objective optimization for L2OC signal (Top 15)
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.500, 2.250) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.462 || 0.130 || 0.732 || 0.000 || 0.750 || 0.732 || 0.734 || 0.791 || 0.628 || 10.8225
+
!Signal
 +
!Antijamming<br>w=8.00
 +
!Accurancy<br>w=9.00 
 +
!MultiPath<br>w=6.00 
 +
!Inter from<br>w=3.00
 +
!Inter to<br>w=1.00
 +
!Search<br>w=8.00
 +
!Complexity<br>w=10.00
 +
!Intra<br>w=7.00
 +
!Norm
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.500, 2.250) at 1567<math>f_b</math> || 0.462 || 0.793 || 0.732 || 0.000 || 0.828 || 0.811 || 0.734 || 0.823 || 0.628 || 11.0488
+
|BPSK(2.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.398 || 0.241 || 0.622 || 0.921 || 0.928 || 0.374 || 0.486 || 0.410 || 8.8359
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.063 || 0.494 || 0.578 || 0.000 || 0.299 || 0.319 || 0.734 || 0.892 || 0.524 || 9.4440
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(1.000, 1.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.309 || 0.153 || 0.363 || 0.842 || 0.855 || 0.374 || 0.647 || 0.289 || 8.6478
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.063 || 0.915 || 0.578 || 0.000 || 0.180 || 0.264 || 0.734 || 1.000 || 0.524 || 9.9340
+
|BPSK(1.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.523 || 0.321 || 0.747 || 0.935 || 0.941 || 0.281 || 0.486 || 0.529 || 9.8518
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.330 || 0.987 || 0.692 || 0.000 || 0.692 || 0.728 || 0.775 || 0.836 || 0.502 || 10.1274
+
|BPSK(2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.301 || 0.192 || 0.521 || 0.908 || 0.916 || 0.479 || 0.647 || 0.314 || 9.3934
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.330 || 0.273 || 0.692 || 0.000 || 0.642 || 0.646 || 0.775 || 0.944 || 0.502 || 10.2730
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(1.000, 1.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.374 || 0.198 || 0.615 || 0.892 || 0.901 || 0.374 || 0.649 || 0.409 || 9.6468
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(3.125, 2.500) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.789 || 0.928 || 0.999 || 0.000 || 0.859 || 0.893 || 0.816 || 0.893 || 0.314 || 12.0623
+
|BPSK(3.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.222 || 0.160 || 0.439 || 0.898 || 0.907 || 0.587 || 0.647 || 0.237 || 9.3273
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.201 || 0.074 || 0.659 || 0.000 || 0.600 || 0.690 || 0.816 || 0.666 || 0.402 || 8.7317
+
|BPSK(2.000) at 1219<math>f_b</math> || 0.398 || 0.241 || 0.622 || 0.969 || 0.973 || 0.374 || 0.674 || 0.410 || 10.0441
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.201 || 0.694 || 0.659 || 0.000 || 0.530 || 0.601 || 0.816 || 0.774 || 0.402 || 9.1287
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(0.500, 0.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.610 || 0.308 || 0.611 || 0.916 || 0.923 || 0.179 || 0.564 || 0.576 || 10.1700
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.079 || 0.210 || 0.630 || 0.000 || 0.508 || 0.573 || 0.857 || 0.885 || 0.311 || 8.9746
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(1.000, 0.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.434 || 0.172 || 0.321 || 0.843 || 0.856 || 0.179 || 0.727 || 0.541 || 9.7248
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1566<math>f_b</math> || 0.079 || 0.848 || 0.630 || 0.000 || 0.421 || 0.547 || 0.857 || 0.994 || 0.311 || 9.4985
+
|BPSK(2.000) at 1215<math>f_b</math> || 0.398 || 0.241 || 0.622 || 0.863 || 0.869 || 0.374 || 0.728 || 0.410 || 10.3202
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.250, 1.750) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.994 || 0.852 || 0.970 || 0.000 || 0.820 || 0.889 || 0.559 || 0.739 || 0.904 || 14.7015
+
|BPSK(1.750) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.456 || 0.277 || 0.682 || 0.928 || 0.935 || 0.328 || 0.688 || 0.468 || 10.4798
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.250, 1.875) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.934 || 0.881 || 0.968 || 0.000 || 0.820 || 0.887 || 0.599 || 0.875 || 0.791 || 14.1146
+
|BPSK(1.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.699 || 0.481 || 0.910 || 0.947 || 0.952 || 0.179 || 0.324 || 0.697 || 11.1871
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(5.125, 1.875) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.170 || 0.961 || 0.621 || 0.000 || 0.594 || 0.631 || 0.599 || 0.978 || 0.794 || 11.4774
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(1.000, 0.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.487 || 0.184 || 0.598 || 0.868 || 0.879 || 0.179 || 0.727 || 0.578 || 10.4730
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.000, 2.000) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.894 || 0.000 || 0.996 || 0.000 || 0.848 || 0.862 || 0.639 || 0.601 || 0.730 || 13.0923
+
|BPSK(2.250) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.347 || 0.214 || 0.568 || 0.914 || 0.922 || 0.431 || 0.769 || 0.358 || 10.4231
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.250, 2.000) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.888 || 0.905 || 0.967 || 0.000 || 0.825 || 0.886 || 0.639 || 0.750 || 0.665 || 13.0402
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(1.500, 1.000) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.211 || 0.111 || 0.229 || 0.817 || 0.835 || 0.374 || 0.863 || 0.263 || 9.9612
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
== L2SC ==
 +
 
 +
{| class="wikitable sortable" border="1"
 +
|+ Multi-objective optimization for L2SC signal (Top 15)
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.375, 2.250) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.605 || 0.666 || 0.885 || 0.000 || 0.771 || 0.844 || 0.734 || 0.902 || 0.488 || 11.3579
+
!Signal
 +
!Antijamming<br>w=8.00
 +
!Accurancy<br>w=6.00 
 +
!MultiPath<br>w=2.00 
 +
!Inter from<br>w=2.00
 +
!Inter to<br>w=1.00
 +
!Search<br>w=6.00
 +
!Complexity<br>w=6.00
 +
!Intra<br>w=10.00
 +
!Norm
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.125, 2.500) at 1563<math>f_b</math> || 0.790 || 0.922 || 1.000 || 0.000 || 0.860 || 0.893 || 0.816 || 0.893 || 0.314 || 12.0682
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.437 || 0.011 || 0.340 || 0.386 || 0.952 || 0.369 || 0.020 || 6.7139
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(2.750, 2.750) at 1565<math>f_b</math> || 0.669 || 0.723 || 0.996 || 0.000 || 1.000 || 1.000 || 0.897 || 0.568 || 0.188 || 10.7525
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.188 || 0.495 || 0.012 || 0.532 || 0.571 || 0.952 || 0.301 || 0.016 || 6.9621
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(2.875, 2.875) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.559 || 0.848 || 0.953 || 0.000 || 0.856 || 0.867 || 0.938 || 0.856 || 0.095 || 10.8720
+
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.199 || 0.495 || 0.090 || 0.539 || 0.578 || 0.952 || 0.300 || 0.014 || 6.9856
 
|- align="center"
 
|- align="center"
−
|BoCcos(3.000, 3.000) at 1564<math>f_b</math> || 0.453 || 0.418 || 0.913 || 0.000 || 0.833 || 0.845 || 1.000 || 0.644 || 0.000 || 9.9154
+
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1219<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.437 || 0.011 || 0.048 || 0.100 || 0.952 || 0.513 || 0.020 || 7.0033
−
|}  
+
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.218 || 0.465 || 0.074 || 0.557 || 0.576 || 0.952 || 0.369 || 0.040 || 7.0819
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.750, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.126 || 0.470 || 0.008 || 0.483 || 0.521 || 0.952 || 0.458 || 0.016 || 7.1003
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.750, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.135 || 0.470 || 0.080 || 0.487 || 0.526 || 0.952 || 0.458 || 0.015 || 7.1117
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1218<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.437 || 0.011 || 0.017 || 0.000 || 0.952 || 0.575 || 0.020 || 7.1719
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1219<math>f_b</math> || 0.188 || 0.495 || 0.012 || 0.330 || 0.379 || 0.952 || 0.445 || 0.016 || 7.1727
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1219<math>f_b</math> || 0.199 || 0.495 || 0.090 || 0.343 || 0.393 || 0.952 || 0.444 || 0.014 || 7.1953
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1218<math>f_b</math> || 0.188 || 0.495 || 0.012 || 0.184 || 0.218 || 0.952 || 0.506 || 0.016 || 7.2910
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.500, 2.500) at 1218<math>f_b</math> || 0.199 || 0.495 || 0.090 || 0.200 || 0.233 || 0.952 || 0.505 || 0.014 || 7.3119
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.250, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.251 || 0.522 || 0.018 || 0.573 || 0.624 || 0.952 || 0.389 || 0.016 || 7.3253
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 2.500) at 1219<math>f_b</math> || 0.218 || 0.465 || 0.074 || 0.375 || 0.399 || 0.952 || 0.513 || 0.040 || 7.3390
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.000, 2.500) at 1220<math>f_b</math> || 0.318 || 0.554 || 0.023 || 0.609 || 0.673 || 0.952 || 0.230 || 0.015 || 7.3491
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
== Частотный диапазон L3 ==
 +
 
 +
=== L3SC/OC ===
 +
 
 +
{| class="wikitable sortable" border="1"
 +
|+ Multi-objective optimization for L3SC signal (Top 15)
 +
|- align="center"
 +
!Signal
 +
!Antijamming<br>w=10.00
 +
!Accurancy<br>w=5.00 
 +
!MultiPath<br>w=5.00 
 +
!Inter from<br>w=5.00
 +
!Inter to<br>w=5.00
 +
!Search<br>w=5.00
 +
!Complexity<br>w=7.00
 +
!Intra<br>w=10.00
 +
!Norm
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.000, 4.000) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.085 || 0.629 || 0.026 || 0.165 || 0.841 || 0.784 || 0.909 || 0.000 || 9.2080
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.500, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.232 || 0.628 || 0.003 || 0.200 || 0.716 || 0.686 || 0.974 || 0.132 || 9.4380
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.500, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.260 || 0.632 || 0.081 || 0.208 || 0.713 || 0.686 || 0.975 || 0.190 || 9.6233
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(3.750, 3.750) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.373 || 0.670 || 0.035 || 0.192 || 0.745 || 0.735 || 1.000 || 0.209 || 10.3351
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BPSK(10.000) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.000 || 0.798 || 0.046 || 0.692 || 0.170 || 1.000 || 1.000 || 0.230 || 10.3895
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.000, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.522 || 0.701 || 0.014 || 0.294 || 0.633 || 0.686 || 0.920 || 0.187 || 10.4160
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.000, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.539 || 0.701 || 0.103 || 0.299 || 0.636 || 0.686 || 0.920 || 0.198 || 10.5435
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(5.000, 3.000) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.211 || 0.575 || 0.000 || 0.088 || 0.816 || 0.588 || 0.945 || 0.594 || 10.8294
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BPSK(9.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.230 || 0.835 || 0.055 || 0.699 || 0.143 || 0.950 || 1.000 || 0.385 || 11.0414
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(5.000, 3.000) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.302 || 0.579 || 0.067 || 0.115 || 0.710 || 0.588 || 0.945 || 0.675 || 11.3340
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(3.750, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.675 || 0.742 || 0.019 || 0.351 || 0.577 || 0.686 || 0.983 || 0.187 || 11.5471
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(3.750, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.695 || 0.746 || 0.117 || 0.361 || 0.593 || 0.686 || 0.983 || 0.215 || 11.7622
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(3.500, 3.500) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.684 || 0.720 || 0.046 || 0.235 || 0.591 || 0.686 || 0.864 || 0.469 || 11.8400
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BOC<sub>sin</sub>(4.000, 3.250) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.681 || 0.705 || 0.105 || 0.286 || 0.629 || 0.637 || 0.993 || 0.375 || 11.9800
 +
|- align="center"
 +
|BoC<sub>cos</sub>(4.000, 3.250) at 1175<math>f_b</math> || 0.680 || 0.706 || 0.016 || 0.284 || 0.629 || 0.637 || 0.994 || 0.413 || 12.0910
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
== Примечания ==
 +
{{примечания}}
 
{{wl-publish: 2011-12-03 04:13:19 +0400 | Korogodin }}
 
{{wl-publish: 2011-12-03 04:13:19 +0400 | Korogodin }}

Текущая версия на 02:39, 18 марта 2013

Результаты расчетов

Содержание

[править] Частотный диапазон L1

[править] L1OC

Multi-objective optimization for L1OC signal
Signal Antijamming
w=8.00 		Astronomy
w=2.00 		Accurancy
w=9.00 		MultiPath
w=6.00 		Inter from
w=3.00 		Inter to
w=1.00 		Search
w=8.00 		Complexity
w=10.00 		Intra
w=7.00 		Norm
BPSK(1.000) at 1565f_b 0.613 0.201 0.481 0.910 0.968 0.974 0.304 0.465 0.603 11.2942
BPSK(2.000) at 1565f_b 0.226 0.463 0.241 0.622 0.936 0.951 0.638 0.731 0.226 10.6568
BPSK(1.500) at 1565f_b 0.387 0.431 0.321 0.747 0.952 0.963 0.478 0.731 0.383 11.0965
BPSK(1.250) at 1565f_b 0.489 0.350 0.386 0.824 0.960 0.969 0.389 0.931 0.484 13.0092
BOCsin(0.500, 0.500) at 1565f_b 0.582 0.727 0.397 0.888 0.949 0.961 0.304 0.868 0.608 13.1624
BOCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1565f_b 0.195 1.000 0.198 0.615 0.902 0.927 0.638 1.000 0.226 12.6465
BPSK(2.500) at 1565f_b 0.102 0.599 0.192 0.521 0.919 0.938 0.815 0.997 0.101 12.8749
BPSK(1.000) at 1566f_b 0.613 0.360 0.481 0.910 0.975 0.979 0.304 0.908 0.603 13.7449
BPSK(3.000) at 1565f_b 0.000 0.844 0.160 0.439 0.905 0.927 1.000 0.997 0.000 13.5461
BPSK(0.750) at 1565f_b 0.774 0.091 0.642 1.002 0.976 0.980 0.228 0.804 0.759 14.6179
BoCcos(0.250, 0.250) at 1565f_b 0.886 0.485 0.614 0.808 0.947 0.959 0.145 0.998 0.833 15.7857
BPSK(0.500) at 1565f_b 1.000 0.000 1.000 1.092 0.987 0.988 0.145 0.465 1.000 16.4224
BOCsin(0.250, 0.250) at 1565f_b 0.970 0.140 0.792 1.000 0.966 0.972 0.145 0.996 0.989 17.4602
BPSK(0.500) at 1566f_b 1.000 0.117 1.000 1.092 1.000 1.000 0.145 0.908 1.000 18.1902
BPSK(0.500) at 1570f_b 1.000 0.842 1.000 1.092 0.000 0.000 0.145 0.997 1.000 18.4540

[править] L1SC

Multi-objective optimization for L1SC signal (Top 15)
Signal Antijamming
w=8.00 		Astronomy
w=2.00 		Accurancy
w=6.00 		MultiPath
w=2.00 		Inter from
w=2.00 		Inter to
w=1.00 		Search
w=6.00 		Complexity
w=6.00 		Intra
w=10.00 		Norm
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1565f_b 0.201 0.074 0.659 0.074 0.600 0.690 0.816 0.666 0.402 8.7330
BOCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1565f_b 0.079 0.210 0.630 0.064 0.508 0.573 0.857 0.885 0.311 8.9755
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1566f_b 0.201 0.694 0.659 0.074 0.530 0.601 0.816 0.774 0.402 9.1299
BOCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1565f_b 0.063 0.494 0.578 0.056 0.299 0.319 0.734 0.892 0.524 9.4447
BOCsin(5.250, 2.625) at 1566f_b 0.079 0.848 0.630 0.064 0.421 0.547 0.857 0.994 0.311 9.4994
BOCsin(6.000, 2.000) at 1565f_b 0.000 0.718 0.538 0.050 0.080 0.083 0.639 0.676 0.720 9.7748
BoCcos(3.000, 3.000) at 1564f_b 0.453 0.418 0.913 0.071 0.833 0.845 1.000 0.644 0.000 9.9164
BOCsin(5.625, 2.250) at 1566f_b 0.063 0.915 0.578 0.056 0.180 0.264 0.734 1.000 0.524 9.9347
BOCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1565f_b 0.330 0.987 0.692 0.082 0.692 0.728 0.775 0.836 0.502 10.1288
BOCsin(4.750, 2.375) at 1566f_b 0.330 0.273 0.692 0.082 0.642 0.646 0.775 0.944 0.502 10.2743
BOCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1565f_b 0.352 0.561 0.650 0.076 0.538 0.648 0.639 0.607 0.770 10.6395
BoCcos(2.750, 2.750) at 1565f_b 0.669 0.723 0.996 0.088 1.000 1.000 0.897 0.568 0.188 10.7539
BOCsin(4.500, 2.250) at 1566f_b 0.462 0.130 0.732 0.092 0.750 0.732 0.734 0.791 0.628 10.8240
BOCsin(5.000, 2.000) at 1566f_b 0.352 0.406 0.650 0.076 0.427 0.518 0.639 0.716 0.770 10.8252
BoCcos(2.875, 2.875) at 1564f_b 0.559 0.848 0.953 0.079 0.856 0.867 0.938 0.856 0.095 10.8732

[править] Частотный диапазон L2

[править] L2OC

Multi-objective optimization for L2OC signal (Top 15)
Signal Antijamming
w=8.00 		Accurancy
w=9.00 		MultiPath
w=6.00 		Inter from
w=3.00 		Inter to
w=1.00 		Search
w=8.00 		Complexity
w=10.00 		Intra
w=7.00 		Norm
BPSK(2.000) at 1220f_b 0.398 0.241 0.622 0.921 0.928 0.374 0.486 0.410 8.8359
BoCcos(1.000, 1.000) at 1220f_b 0.309 0.153 0.363 0.842 0.855 0.374 0.647 0.289 8.6478
BPSK(1.500) at 1220f_b 0.523 0.321 0.747 0.935 0.941 0.281 0.486 0.529 9.8518
BPSK(2.500) at 1220f_b 0.301 0.192 0.521 0.908 0.916 0.479 0.647 0.314 9.3934
BOCsin(1.000, 1.000) at 1220f_b 0.374 0.198 0.615 0.892 0.901 0.374 0.649 0.409 9.6468
BPSK(3.000) at 1220f_b 0.222 0.160 0.439 0.898 0.907 0.587 0.647 0.237 9.3273
BPSK(2.000) at 1219f_b 0.398 0.241 0.622 0.969 0.973 0.374 0.674 0.410 10.0441
BoCcos(0.500, 0.500) at 1220f_b 0.610 0.308 0.611 0.916 0.923 0.179 0.564 0.576 10.1700
BoCcos(1.000, 0.500) at 1220f_b 0.434 0.172 0.321 0.843 0.856 0.179 0.727 0.541 9.7248
BPSK(2.000) at 1215f_b 0.398 0.241 0.622 0.863 0.869 0.374 0.728 0.410 10.3202
BPSK(1.750) at 1220f_b 0.456 0.277 0.682 0.928 0.935 0.328 0.688 0.468 10.4798
BPSK(1.000) at 1220f_b 0.699 0.481 0.910 0.947 0.952 0.179 0.324 0.697 11.1871
BOCsin(1.000, 0.500) at 1220f_b 0.487 0.184 0.598 0.868 0.879 0.179 0.727 0.578 10.4730
BPSK(2.250) at 1220f_b 0.347 0.214 0.568 0.914 0.922 0.431 0.769 0.358 10.4231
BoCcos(1.500, 1.000) at 1220f_b 0.211 0.111 0.229 0.817 0.835 0.374 0.863 0.263 9.9612

[править] L2SC

Multi-objective optimization for L2SC signal (Top 15)
Signal Antijamming
w=8.00 		Accurancy
w=6.00 		MultiPath
w=2.00 		Inter from
w=2.00 		Inter to
w=1.00 		Search
w=6.00 		Complexity
w=6.00 		Intra
w=10.00 		Norm
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.000 0.437 0.011 0.340 0.386 0.952 0.369 0.020 6.7139
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.188 0.495 0.012 0.532 0.571 0.952 0.301 0.016 6.9621
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.199 0.495 0.090 0.539 0.578 0.952 0.300 0.014 6.9856
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1219f_b 0.000 0.437 0.011 0.048 0.100 0.952 0.513 0.020 7.0033
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.218 0.465 0.074 0.557 0.576 0.952 0.369 0.040 7.0819
BoCcos(4.750, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.126 0.470 0.008 0.483 0.521 0.952 0.458 0.016 7.1003
BOCsin(4.750, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.135 0.470 0.080 0.487 0.526 0.952 0.458 0.015 7.1117
BoCcos(5.000, 2.500) at 1218f_b 0.000 0.437 0.011 0.017 0.000 0.952 0.575 0.020 7.1719
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1219f_b 0.188 0.495 0.012 0.330 0.379 0.952 0.445 0.016 7.1727
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1219f_b 0.199 0.495 0.090 0.343 0.393 0.952 0.444 0.014 7.1953
BoCcos(4.500, 2.500) at 1218f_b 0.188 0.495 0.012 0.184 0.218 0.952 0.506 0.016 7.2910
BOCsin(4.500, 2.500) at 1218f_b 0.199 0.495 0.090 0.200 0.233 0.952 0.505 0.014 7.3119
BoCcos(4.250, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.251 0.522 0.018 0.573 0.624 0.952 0.389 0.016 7.3253
BOCsin(5.000, 2.500) at 1219f_b 0.218 0.465 0.074 0.375 0.399 0.952 0.513 0.040 7.3390
BoCcos(4.000, 2.500) at 1220f_b 0.318 0.554 0.023 0.609 0.673 0.952 0.230 0.015 7.3491

[править] Частотный диапазон L3

[править] L3SC/OC

Multi-objective optimization for L3SC signal (Top 15)
Signal Antijamming
w=10.00 		Accurancy
w=5.00 		MultiPath
w=5.00 		Inter from
w=5.00 		Inter to
w=5.00 		Search
w=5.00 		Complexity
w=7.00 		Intra
w=10.00 		Norm
BoCcos(4.000, 4.000) at 1175f_b 0.085 0.629 0.026 0.165 0.841 0.784 0.909 0.000 9.2080
BoCcos(4.500, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.232 0.628 0.003 0.200 0.716 0.686 0.974 0.132 9.4380
BOCsin(4.500, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.260 0.632 0.081 0.208 0.713 0.686 0.975 0.190 9.6233
BoCcos(3.750, 3.750) at 1175f_b 0.373 0.670 0.035 0.192 0.745 0.735 1.000 0.209 10.3351
BPSK(10.000) at 1175f_b 0.000 0.798 0.046 0.692 0.170 1.000 1.000 0.230 10.3895
BoCcos(4.000, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.522 0.701 0.014 0.294 0.633 0.686 0.920 0.187 10.4160
BOCsin(4.000, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.539 0.701 0.103 0.299 0.636 0.686 0.920 0.198 10.5435
BoCcos(5.000, 3.000) at 1175f_b 0.211 0.575 0.000 0.088 0.816 0.588 0.945 0.594 10.8294
BPSK(9.500) at 1175f_b 0.230 0.835 0.055 0.699 0.143 0.950 1.000 0.385 11.0414
BOCsin(5.000, 3.000) at 1175f_b 0.302 0.579 0.067 0.115 0.710 0.588 0.945 0.675 11.3340
BoCcos(3.750, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.675 0.742 0.019 0.351 0.577 0.686 0.983 0.187 11.5471
BOCsin(3.750, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.695 0.746 0.117 0.361 0.593 0.686 0.983 0.215 11.7622
BoCcos(3.500, 3.500) at 1175f_b 0.684 0.720 0.046 0.235 0.591 0.686 0.864 0.469 11.8400
BOCsin(4.000, 3.250) at 1175f_b 0.681 0.705 0.105 0.286 0.629 0.637 0.993 0.375 11.9800
BoCcos(4.000, 3.250) at 1175f_b 0.680 0.706 0.016 0.284 0.629 0.637 0.994 0.413 12.0910

[править] Примечания

Неизвестный тег расширения «references»

— Корогодин Илья • 04:13, 3 декабря 2011 • нет комментариев

[ Хронологический вид ]Комментарии

(нет элементов)

Войдите, чтобы комментировать.

Источник — «https://acik.srns.ru/index.php?title=Blog:Korogodin/02.12.2011,_Результаты_многокритериальной_оптимизации&oldid=7673»
Персональные инструменты
Пространства имён

Варианты
Действия
SRNS Wiki
Рабочие журналы
Приватный файлсервер
QNAP Сервер
Инструменты